Review Queue

5 open items from local rules and agent review.

Total 5 Open 5 Provider codex Provider status completed

Draft PR output exceeds the source-publish workflow

warn

RI-9B2AB0259BB2 - github-public-source-publish - boundary_output_overreach

The registry promises a draft pull request artifact, while the skill body frames completion around publishing a source repository.

Suggested Action

Either document and validate a real draft-PR mode, or narrow the manifest to the source-publish artifacts the workflow actually owns.

Evidence

  • github-public-source-publish-skill/manifest.yaml trigger_phrases and outputs
    trigger_phrases: - publish source to GitHub - create public repo - open draft PR outputs: - initialized git repository - public GitHub remote - source-only initial commit - draft pull request when requested
  • github-public-source-publish-skill/SKILL.md Purpose
    Use this skill to publish a local static-site source directory as a public GitHub source repository. It is source-publish only: it does not deploy the site, configure Cloudflare Pages, or manage DNS.
human decisionopen

Diagnosis wording conflicts with the non-algorithm boundary

warn

RI-B82FCA827742 - personal-color-analysis - boundary_output_overreach

The skill body uses diagnosis-from-photo wording even though the declared boundary says the skill does not perform automatic computer-vision diagnosis.

Suggested Action

Tighten positive trigger and overview language around supplied diagnosis data and report-card generation.

Evidence

  • personal-color-analysis-skill/SKILL.md Overview
    vertical dashboard-style visuals that diagnose a person's best color palette from a portrait photo
  • personal-color-analysis-skill/SKILL.md Scope
    It does not perform computer-vision diagnosis on the photo. Instead, it provides the structured prompts, color theory references, and layout rules needed to generate professional report cards via GPT-image-2.
  • personal-color-analysis-skill/manifest.yaml do_not_use_when
    do_not_use_when: - The user expects the skill to perform computer-vision color diagnosis automatically.
human decisionopen

Publish wording overlaps source publishing and deployment

warn

RI-C02332E520DB - cloudflare-pages-deploy - boundary_trigger_ambiguity

The Cloudflare skill uses generic publish language while the GitHub skill owns source publishing, creating a routing ambiguity for requests like publishing a static site.

Suggested Action

Clarify the trigger phrasing on both sides and keep the workflows separate; do not merge them automatically.

Evidence

  • cloudflare-pages-skill/manifest.yaml trigger_phrases
    trigger_phrases: - deploy to Cloudflare Pages - publish static site - direct upload Pages
  • github-public-source-publish-skill/manifest.yaml trigger_phrases and do_not_use_when
    trigger_phrases: - publish source to GitHub - create public repo - open draft PR do_not_use_when: - The user wants to deploy or host the site rather than publish source.
human decisionopen

Platform boundary is only documented in the skill body

warn

RI-8EC9D12C4E13 - github-public-source-publish - boundary_weakness

The manifest exposes deployment and repository-privacy exclusions, but not the macOS-only platform boundary stated in SKILL.md.

Suggested Action

Expose the platform exclusion in manifest boundaries or make the manifest use_when explicitly macOS-scoped.

Evidence

  • github-public-source-publish-skill/SKILL.md Runtime requirements
    This skill is macOS-only. Always use the workspace venv interpreter after the first bootstrap:
  • github-public-source-publish-skill/manifest.yaml do_not_use_when
    do_not_use_when: - The user wants to deploy or host the site rather than publish source. - The target repository must remain private or requires complex organization policy setup.
no human decision requiredopen

Output template is not represented in manifest dependencies

warn

RI-4D48265A58CE - personal-color-analysis - dep_unreferenced_template

The manifest requires an output template but declares no template dependency, while the actual prompt template lives under resources.

Suggested Action

Decide whether resource-hosted prompt templates should be declared as template dependencies or moved into the canonical template surface.

Evidence

  • personal-color-analysis-skill/manifest.yaml dependencies and quality_gates
    dependencies: skills: [] templates: [] rubrics: [] quality_gates: requires_examples: false requires_do_not_use_when: true requires_output_template: true
  • personal-color-analysis-skill/SKILL.md Resource map
    | The complete GPT-image-2 prompt template with fillable variable slots | `resources/master-prompt-template.md` |
  • personal-color-analysis-skill/resources/master-prompt-template.md Introduction
    This resource contains the complete GPT-image-2 prompt template for generating a professional Personal Color Analysis (PCA) infographic report card.
human decisionopen